Language

Search for article

When the map hits the mud: A conversation with ecologist Rhett Harrison

Pitfalls and positive spinoffs of setting up biodiversity monitoring grids on the Managalas Plateau.
Ecologist Rhett Harrison, with long grey hair in braids and wearing a plaid shirt, gestures while standing next to a presentation board displaying a map titled "Camera Traps and Sound" inside a classroom.
Rhett Harrison teaches Managalas Biodiversity Team Leaders about monitoring methods. Photo by Russell Wai / Landscape Alliance

This is the third in a three-part series examining conservation on Papua New Guineaโ€™s Managalas Plateau. The first two instalments covered the launch of a broad-scale biodiversity mapping project and a conversation with biologist Gabriel Leite on using bioacoustics to track elusive species.

Finding out whatโ€™s in a forest is never just an academic process. Itโ€™s also a practical and physical challenge, as the scratches all over senior landscape ecologist Rhett Harrisonโ€™s legs attest.  

Sitting on suitcases in the Landscape Allianceโ€™s new Port Moresby office (itโ€™s so new the furniture is yet to arrive!), Harrison recounts his recent trip to the Managalas Plateau in Oro Province, where the organisation is supporting community management of the Managalas Conservation Area (MCA), which protects 214,696 hectares of tropical forests and grasslands. โ€œThis is a very difficult rainforest to move around in,โ€ he says. โ€œItโ€™s tough going.โ€ 

Harrisonโ€™s trip was focused on setting up camera traps and sound recorders to gather baseline wildlife data, alongside a group of young local Biodiversity Team Leaders (BTLs) who have been trained to deploy devices and conduct surveys in their own land. 

First, the team chose 18 sites to set up monitoring stations, using a process called stratified random sampling. They drew a grid of points across the plateau, categorised each point on it according to one of three elevation bands and one of two underlying geology types (making six categories altogether), and then randomly selected three grid points for each of the six categories. Each point then became the corner of a 3-square-kilometre grid with 49 stations at half-kilometre intervals.  

So far, so straightforward โ€” but the deployment process was another story. The team pulled on their boots and headed out to set up monitoring stations at four of the grids. Out in the bush, they discovered many things that the maps had missed. The last install was โ€œone of the hardest days I’ve ever had,โ€ says Harrison. After hiking in along a village trail for a few hours with all their camping gear, they set up camp at the edge of the grid and then set off to deploy the camera traps and sound recorders.  

โ€œIt looks flat on the map because there are not too many contours, but in fact itโ€™s a series of small streams running off a slope,โ€ says Harrison. โ€œEach little valley is only maybe 20 or 30 metres difference in elevation, but you’re just constantly climbing up and down these very steep banks, over and over and over and over again.โ€ 

A tropical storm had also come through recently, meaning โ€œthere were fallen trees all over the place and we had to cut our way through,โ€ says Harrison. โ€œJust to go the three kilometres across the site took us almost three hours.โ€ They set up just three of the seven traps they were aiming for that day, and then had to return to their camp and come back again the next day. 

The experience got Harrison wondering if he might be ageing out of this kind of fieldwork.

โ€œWhen we started the mapping, I was like, โ€˜I really want to do that.โ€™ Now, after that experience, I’m thinking maybe itโ€™s a bit much โ€” Iโ€™m no longer 25!โ€ he laughs. He wasnโ€™t the only one who found it tough, though. The BTL who came with him coped OK, โ€œbut the two people from the local village who came with us were in full mutiny!โ€ he laughed.  

You might think those locals would know the landscapes like the palms of their hands, but all forest here has its owners, and most people here just know specific parts of their clanโ€™s land โ€” usually a select few hunting spots. โ€œThey don’t tend to go off the trails very far; theyโ€™re not going out there exploring,โ€ said Harrison. 

Will Unsworth, Rhett Harrison, and a local community elder sit at a wooden table during an indoor workshop, smiling and conversing with meeting papers and pens laid out before them.
Will Unsworth, Rhett Harrison and George Tumai on the Managalas Plateau. Photo by Russell Wai / Landscape Alliance
A group of local men work together in a dense forest to install a camouflaged camera trap onto a slender tree trunk, with notebooks and equipment bags open on the jungle floor.
Biodiversity Team Leaders (BLTs) set up a camera trap.
Photo by Russell Wai / Landscape Alliance
Three men crouch low on the leafy forest floor, focusing intently as they adjust and strap a camouflaged camera trap to a thin tree trunk amidst dense undergrowth.
BTLs set up camera traps. Photo by Russell Wai / CIFOR-ICRAF

The BTLsโ€™ work was facilitated by cell phones: they record their movements on one app, and the installation and recovery of the instruments on another, and they have to follow the GPS compass to get where they’re going. โ€œIt requires a few skills to get it done,โ€ says Harrison.  

Motivation, however, was high. โ€œThese BTLs are among the most committed, conservation-minded young people on the plateau,โ€ says Harrison. โ€œAnd that reflects all the work that previous NGOs did in terms of education. They also have a really clear idea of what the communities need in return for gazetting their land as a nationally recognized Protected Area, so theyโ€™re very valuable team members.โ€ 

One practical challenge is setting up the camera traps to capture wildlife well in rugged terrain.

The BTLs were trained to focus the cameras on the ground about 4.5 metres in front of them, but when a site is steep, itโ€™s hard to work out optimal positioning. โ€œItโ€™s actually quite challenging,โ€ says Harrison: โ€œthe setting of the camera trap is the main determinant of how much you’re going to see, and that’s going to change every time.โ€ 

The sound recorders, which help to identify the presence of animals that make noise, are more straightforward to set up. Theyโ€™re collected after just two weeks of recording, in contrast to the camera traps, which are left out for four. This reflects the sheer volume of information the audio devices collect.

โ€œYou generate terabytes worth of data, so data management becomes a real headache if you leave them out for longer โ€” and the science suggests that the extra time does not lead to better estimates of the diversity of species,โ€ says Harrison. โ€œThe camera traps need to be left out for longer, because they are recording information less often โ€” only when an animal walks pastโ€. 

Two men look intently as they secure a small green sound recorder to a thin tree branch with a black zip tie in a dense forest.
Biodiversity Team Leaders set up a sound recorder. Photo by Russell Wai / Landscape Alliance

The team still has 10 of the 18 grids to set up, with progress in some places hindered by land tenure disputes and vandalism. Some of the more isolated sites in the high mountains surrounding the plateau, which entail 45-degree slopes and extremely thick forest, may require supply drops by air.  

Theyโ€™ve also recognized the need to get areas scouted by locals before the team goes in, to find the easiest ways to get there and avoid entering or going near sacred sites. โ€œIf you can access a grid via a village trail, it cuts your time to do the work massively compared to trying to cut your way through the forest,โ€ says Harrison.   

While challenging, the work has yielded lots of interesting findings so far. In just the first week of operations, two endangered giant bandicoots (Peroryctes broadbenti) were caught on camera, alongside snakes, frogs, possums, forest wallabies and more.  

The team have also taken preliminary eDNA samples from water bodies in some of the sites, which will help bring further insights into MCAโ€™s vast and largely untracked biodiversity.

Sampling streams also captures DNA washed into the streams, so eDNA is a good way to record those species that are missed by camera traps and sound devices, such as tree kangaroos or other arboreal species that rarely call. 

โ€œIncrementally, we’re getting a better picture of the flora and fauna of the plateau,โ€ says Harrison. โ€œWeโ€™re still missing a lot, but we don’t need everything: what weโ€™re trying to get is a good-enough picture that we can use it as a baseline and for spatial planning in the conservation management plan.โ€ 


For more information on the project, please contact Landscape Allianceโ€™s PNG Program Manager, Will Unsworth: [email protected]